Seneca Village, NY: A Black Community Lost to History

When New York Destroyed a Black Community to Build a Park

William Spivey
4 min readDec 1, 2023

--

By Image by Alfred Hutter, Attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5794950

In 1825, a free Black man named Andrew Williams bought land in the middle of Manhattan. His purchase was followed up by additional purchases by the African Methodist Episcopal Church (AME) for the purpose of developing the land. Most of the inhabitants were free Black people, and over 50% of them owned the homes they lived in. In a land where the vote was limited to property-owning males, many of the Black male residents had the right to vote and did so.

New York had a growing free population. The Gradual Emancipation Laws of 1799 and 1817 would allow enslaved people to age into their freedom when children born to enslaved people reached the ages of 28 for men and 25 for women. They would join the growing population of free Black people that already existed. with free Black people in New York dating back to 1644.

The community of Seneca Village grew rapidly and soon housed several hundred people, including German and Irish immigrants. Blacks and whites attended church side by side. Elsewhere in New York, wealthy white socialites were making plans for a sprawling park to fend off European criticisms that Americans had no appreciation for culture. They wanted a place where they could ride in their carriages to see and be seen. They held a park design contest, ultimately selecting a design by Frederick Law Olmsted, the park superintendent, and Calvert Vaux, an architect. They used the power of eminent domain to take 840 acres to build Central Park, which included all of Seneca Village.

By Alfred Waud — Harper's Weekly, December 16, 1865, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=115702338

There was a huge campaign to denigrate both the land and the people as being of little worth. The land was described as “rocky and swampy,” while what was said of the people was much worse.

“There was a smear campaign that was created in the media: ‘We’ve gotta get rid of all those people that live in the park that shouldn’t be there. They are tramps, squatters, and thieves.’ This is the kind of language that they used.” — Cynthia Copeland, president of the Institute for the Exploration of…

--

--